Why are BAYS® English Muffins in the dairy case? Because that’s where a lot of the best the fresh food is found. Nothing says wholesome and fresh like eggs, butter and milk. So when it’s time to choose English muffins, it makes sense to start where you know the food is always kept fresh, chilled and ready-to-go. Always tender, soft and toaster-ready, those who love English muffins know the delicious difference of freshness from the dairy case.